ATTACHMENT II BACKGROUND MATERNAL DEPRIVATION Clinical studies of extensive maternal deprivation: Animal research: Scott's work with dogs Harlows work with monkeys Interpretations: Maternal Deprivation Stimulus deprivation hypothesis Social stimulation hypothesis MATERNAL EMPLOYMENT Statistics Results INFANT DAY CARE Statititics Results Caveats Quality of Day care Interpretation of Animal Studies: 3 positions: Maternal Deprivation: (The ethological/psychoanalytic speculations by Bowlby): Infants need a single "mother" to attend to their needs during the critical period of infancy. -- Evidence from China and Israel (Kibbutz and mataplots) raised by rotating child rearers did beautifully. And Harlows' monkeys recovered. Stimulus deprivation hypothesis: Understaffed institutional settings are breeding grounds for developmental abnormalities because they provide the infant with a monotonous sensory environment where there is little if any stimulation to encourage any sort of responsiveness. -- Pratt did study with isolated monkeys, showing them "slide shows" of objects, other monkeys, and the like. The slide shows had no effect on the isolated monkeys. -- Provence & Lipton (1962) provided healthy institutionalized children with toys, visual and auditory exposure to other infants; they showed roughly the same retardation as instit. kids without this stimulation. Social stimulation hypothesis: Children need sustained interactions with responsive companions in order to develop normally --a contingent social world. Without the opportunity to learn about mutual control, the children develop "learned helplessness". -Children can recuperate from socially limiting conditions if they are placed in homes where they receive ample doses of individualized attention from affectionate and responsive caregivers (e.g., research by W. Dennis of Lebonese orphanage children). However, if the deprivation begins in the first year, and lasts until the 3rd year, chances of recuperation reduced. MATERNAL EMPLOYMENT: STATISTICS 20% of children are reared in 1-parent families. 7% of families represent the traditional nuclear family, with father as breadwinner, mother as homemaker, with 2 or more children living at home. 62+% of mothers are employed outside home (late ‘80s). Fastest growing group of employed mothers is mothers with children under 1 year of age. Half of such women are working.